About Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC | Columbus, OH

To learn about our agency and our staff, please
click here

  • Facebook Icon
  • Twitter Icon
  • Google Plus Icon

Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC

5640 Groveport Rd Suite 2
Groveport, OH 43125

Phone: 614-295-8816
Fax: 614-409-1840
Email: rschooley@kia-llc.com


call-iconClick to Call
Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC

5640 Groveport Rd Suite 2
Groveport, OH 43125

map-iconGet Directions

Columbus, OH Insurance Agents Serving Groveport, Canal Winchester, Grove City, Hilliard, Gahanna and surrounding areas · Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC

Welcome to Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC! We are Columbus, OH independent insurance agents, and we offer a variety of coverage options including home and auto policies. We are here to guide you through the process of obtaining insurance in Ohio, protecting you and your loved ones from a myriad of risks.

Home insurance comes with specific requirements, including bank and replacement cost criteria. You must obtain enough insurance to meet these criteria while mitigating the risk of being underinsured. You can count on Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC, to help you match your needs to the right insurance policy. Given that your home is one of your most important assets, you must get it insured properly to protect your financial and physical well-being.

As independent insurance agents, we also help our clients obtain the right auto insurance. We help you find the right liability and physical damage coverage to cover bodily injury and property damage. We also assist in setting your deductibles, premium payments, and coverage limits, so that you feel comfortable every time you drive your vehicle. We can help you optimize your coverage to protect you, your loved ones and your personal assets, in the case you are responsible for the accident.

We offer a variety of other insurance products, including commercial, life, flood, and umbrella policies. Whether you need motorcycle or renter’s insurance, we are here to help. Our agents are ready to walk you through all of your options.

For additional information on our products and services, please contact us today. There is no reason to take a risk and go uninsured when there are so many threats to your home, property and physical health.

Rich and Michelle take care of you as if family assuring that one is covered well at a reasonable rate. I highly recommend Keystone Insurance !
Frank Meyers, Grove City, OH

Your best insurance policy is a good agency. The Keystone Insurance Agency is just that and more!
Julie W, Westerville, OH

Refresh live blog posts

Independent Insurance Agent Trusted Choice PIA
Google Review Us



Our Insurance Partners

What some of our clients have to say:

Rich and Michelle always have their customer's best interest in mind. My wife and I just recently entrusted our insurance needs to Keystone and the process was absolutely painless. I would and have highly recommend them for any of your insurance needs.
Jason Kline, Grove City, OH

Rich Schooley & Michelle Mouser are the best!! My company H.T.F. Industries were treated very well and saved a bunch of money. I would and DO recommend this company to anyone with insurance needs. Thanks guys!!
Gary Allen, HTF Industries, Reynoldsburg, OH

We have been very pleased with the advice and service that we have received. Rich and Michelle have taken the initiative many times to see that we are properly insured for the best possible price. It is reassuring to us to know they will take care of us.
Glenn & Sharon Bardus, Grove City, OH

Contact Us

Phone: 614-295-8816
Fax: 614-409-1840
Email: rschooley@kia-llc.com

Address:  5640 Groveport Rd Suite 2
Groveport, OH 43125