Independent Insurance Agent Trusted Choice PIA


Click to Call
Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC

5640 Groveport Rd Suite 2
Groveport, OH 43125

Get Directions
Featured About Us Image

About Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC


Richard Schooley, AAI, AIS

Agency Principal

Rich is the Agency Principal of Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC as of June 1, 2011. He formerly owned and operated The Schooley Insurance Agency. Rich is a member of the Southeastern Franklin County Chamber of Commerce. He is also a member of Professional Independent Insurance Agents Association of Ohio. He is an Accredited Advisor in Insurance and holds an Associate in Insurance Services. His goal is to give sound insurance advice at an affordable cost.


Michelle Schooley

Account Manager

Michelle has been in the insurance industry since 2005. She born and raised in Groveport, Ohio. Michelle graduated from Groveport Madison High School in 2005 and went straight to work in the insurance industry. She is a Certified Professional Insurance Agent. She is a valuable asset to this organization. Her duties include managing accounts and employees. Her commitment is to be your lifelong insurance advisor, providing personal service and attention to detail.


Pamela Mourn

Client Services

Pam joined our team in 2011. She was born and raised in Columbus and has 2 grandchildren. She answers the phones for us, processes payments for you and helps to keep our office organized.


Bonnie Bidlack

Client Services

Bonnie joined our team in 2016. She was born and raised on the Southside of Columbus. Bonnie was an area supervisor for Hallmark for 18 years before she joined our team. She is here to process your payments and make sure your file is up to date.

Business We Support

Steves Auto Glass

Steve’s Auto Glass